I guess WJ decided to delete his entire topic because the discussions weren't going his way (you need to get over that man) but ARROW responded with some interesting comments of interest and I took some time to respond to them myself, and since Ken and I are able to disagree and still be civil and friendly towards each other, here it is...
I think it's a bit naive to pass of radical Islamics and the terrorism that MUSLIMS have spread about the world, as being a "narrow segment of them".
This is the very kind of political correctness that has dumbed down our entire nation and made us not only a target, but the laughing stock of the world, because we've lost our spine to it.
I made a perfectly good series of analogies that speak to the nature of this topic and how we all (AS HUMANS) are entitled to feel a bit nervous around groups of people that are known to have beliefs and or opinions that are negative and even hostile to our own. I brought up the James Byrd incident and concluded that given the heinous and violent nature of what 3 (only 3) WHITE men did to him, that if another Black man was to find himself in a similar situation, walking down a dirt road minding his own business, and a pick-up truck cruises by with 3 or more WHITE men in it, I would not be surprised if that Black man had a moment of panic or concern for himself, and RIGHTFULLY so, without judging him a bigot against ALL White people.
You can't claim to not have defensive and uneasy thoughts or moments about being in the company of people, that have a large population of them, doing great harm to a lot of innocent people.?
Juan Williams spoke on this very issue HONESTLY and was only trying to relate to the mentality of other Americans that share a similar thought when they see MUSLIMS boarding a plane they're about to travel on. Muslims hijacked those planes on 9/11 and Muslims are still trying to pull off attacks against us in the country still to this day. Hardly worth calling people bigots over this kind of honest reaction and THOUGHTS to such a scenario, let alone firing them from a job.
For Juan to say, "hey, I have those kinds of thoughts myself" BUT use it to relate to a large percentage of people in the world, while still proclaiming that it's not REALLY meant to judge ALL Muslims, and make it clear that we really DON'T judge ALL Muslims as "terrorist" but we know that in the world today, it is MUSLIMS that are committing some really awful things against other people of other faiths, and we are entitled to be suspicious, when we're in a vulnerable position, and if getting on a PLANE with Muslims, like what hundreds of people on 9/11 did, unknowing of their fate, is a not VULNERABLE position...I don't know what is. WE still make the flight, deal with our insecurity and fears about seeing people that look like the people that hijacked 4 planes on 9/11 did, and get over it and life goes on as does the plane ride, because we're really more rational peoples, than liberals give us credit for.
Liberals don't give us any credit on that part of the equation (having a fleeting thought but reasoning it out with logic) and only want to focus on the part that makes us "bigoted" in their POV.
A bunch of Black Panthers show up at a KKK rally. Is it so unreasonable that people in the crowd, on one side or the other, might think for a moment "UH-OH"? Why does that thought have to equal discrimination, stereotyping, or bigotry? If ALL BP's and ALL KKK members were violent and hostile against other they don't like, they wouldn't even be able to assemble in the first place. That being said, enough of their members have in FACT done some pretty horrible things in the past, so it's on THEM that we might flinch a little in their presence.
I don't "flinch" because I've just ALWAYS hated ALL Muslims. I flinch, because all my life, I've seen great atrocities committed in the world against Americans by Muslims. I don't think ALL Muslims are like this, but it only takes ONE to royally f@#k up our day, and if I'm getting on an airplane with just ONE.....please allow me that flinch without judging me harshly and unfairly. I'm human and so is Juan Williams.
He related to honest emotions, while at the same time, re-enforcing the reality that while Muslims did kill us on 9/11, that is not to say that we think ALL Muslims are crazy hijacking terrorists, and he (like most Liberals) still seems to think it's on our shoulders to make sure that the Muslim-American community doesn't feel nervous and "finch" around us. oye!!
I don't care that NPR fired Juan and I also don't think there's a lawsuit pending over it, but I do think NPR is STUPID for firing Juan, and for reasons even more stupid. They have a RIGHT to fire anyone they want, but the reasons are entirely lame.